The U.S. energy sector faced a two-sided mandate in 2023–2024: ensure reliable supply amid volatile geopolitics and accelerate the transition to clean energy under increasing policy and investor pressure.
Oil prices whipsawed – after averaging ~$100 in 2022 amid the Ukraine war supply shock, Brent crude averaged around $80 in 2023 easing inflation pressures. The industry is adjusting to moderate prices compared to recent extremes.
Macroeconomic backdrop:
In the US Energy sector, Oil and gas prices swung from peaks to normalization. In mid-2022, crude spiked over $120 (Brent) after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, but by late 2023, prices settled in the $70–$90 range (reuters.com) as global markets adjusted (Russian exports found new buyers, strategic reserves were tapped, and demand growth slowed). U.S. gasoline fell from a record ~$5/gal in June 2022 to about $3.40/gal in summer 2023 (reuters.com), providing relief to consumers and tempering headline inflation. Natural gas told a similar tale: U.S. Henry Hub prices soared to ~$9/mmbtu in mid-2022 amid LNG exports to Europe, then plunged below $3 by early 2023 thanks to a warm winter and ample storage. For energy companies, this price moderation meant record profits of 2022 (when majors like ExxonMobil earned all-time highs) cooled somewhat, but balance sheets remain very strong.
Meanwhile, renewable energy deployment hit record levels – the U.S. added an estimated 25 GW of solar and 11 GW of wind in 2023 (though grid connection bottlenecks slowed some projects). Renewable generation’s share of U.S. electricity exceeded 25% in 2023, an all-time high (energy.gov), surpassing coal for the first time. Government incentives from the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) are catalyzing a factory-building boom for solar panels, wind components, batteries, and EVs on U.S. soil.
Impact on the Energy Sector:
Oil & Gas Industry:
Despite price volatility, upstream investment is rising cautiously. U.S. crude oil production hit ~12.8 million barrels/day in late 2024, a new record (surpassing the 2019 peak (reuters.com), as shale operators responded to earlier high prices and improved productivity. However, producers remain financially disciplined – prioritizing shareholder returns (dividends, buybacks) over aggressive expansion. This approach keeps supply growth moderate, which should prevent a return of oversupply and bust cycles. Oilfield service costs had inflated (drilling rigs and labor in high demand), but stabilized by 2024 as activity leveled. Downstream, refining margins were strong in 2023 with robust fuel demand and some capacity constraints (refineries running ~90%+ utilization). Notably, U.S. LNG exports hit a record – the U.S. was the world’s largest LNG exporter in 2023 at ~11.9 bcf/day (eia.gov ) – as new terminals came online and Europe’s thirst for non-Russian gas remained high. This boosted midstream infrastructure utilization and sparked new LNG project commitments (with several Gulf Coast LNG projects reaching FID by early 2024).
Renewables and Utilities:
Solar and wind developers raced to take advantage of new tax credits, but faced challenges: supply chains (modules, turbines) improved, aided by domestic manufacturing incentives, yet the industry grappled with high interest rates which increase the cost of financing capital-intensive projects. Some utility-scale solar projects were delayed as developers waited for clarity on “made in USA” bonus credits and dealt with interconnection delays to plug into the grid. Utilities themselves are navigating a complex landscape – on one hand, benefiting from electrification trends (EVs, electric heating boosting power demand), on the other, needing to retire fossil plants and invest massively in grid upgrades and storage to accommodate renewables.
Key Trends and Disruptions in the US Energy Sector:
Energy Transition Acceleration:
The IRA, with ~$370B for clean energy, fundamentally shifts economics. By 2024, analysts expect solar and wind LCOE (levelized cost) to drop below even existing coal plants’ operating costs in many regions, spurring more aggressive utility decarbonization plans. For example, Xcel Energy announced closure of all coal by 2030 in favor of renewables and storage. Hydrogen is emerging – dozens of hydrogen project hubs got DOE funding, aiming to use surplus renewables to produce green hydrogen for industry and heavy transport. EV adoption (as noted, ~7.5% of new car sales) is starting to dent gasoline demand growth, though oil for petrochemicals and jet fuel remains robust.
Geopolitical Realignment:
Energy security is back on the agenda. Europe weaned off much of Russian gas by importing U.S. LNG (reuters.com) and accelerating renewables, highlighting opportunity for U.S. gas exporters. OPEC+ showed cohesion in managing oil supply – Saudi and others made voluntary cuts to defend ~$80+ oil, meaning U.S. producers operate in a market more influenced by a few large players. Geopolitics also affected critical minerals (lithium, cobalt): the U.S. and allies launched partnerships to secure these inputs for batteries, mindful of not trading one dependency (oil) for another (minerals controlled by China).
Climate and ESG Pressure:
2023 saw the highest global CO2 emissions on record (despite all efforts, economic growth and coal usage in Asia drove emissions up). Climate impacts – wildfires, heat waves – kept the issue in headlines. Activist investors continued pushing oil majors to invest more in renewables or set net-zero targets (with mixed success – Exxon and Chevron doubled down on oil/gas, while BP and Shell walked back some transition commitments under investor pressure to improve returns). Banks and insurers are gradually tightening lending for high-carbon projects, although state-backed financing (and demand from developing nations) still supports new fossil fuel developments. Essentially, public scrutiny on energy companies’ climate strategies is intense, influencing talent recruitment and long-term valuations.
Strategic Imperatives for Energy Sector Leaders:
Balance Short-Term Returns with Long-Term Transition:
Energy CEOs must execute a delicate balancing act – monetize hydrocarbons efficiently today while investing in tomorrow’s low-carbon businesses. I
Imperative: Maintain capital discipline in oil & gas – focus on highest-return projects (e.g., shale plays with breakevens <$40) and use technology (digital oilfield, AI for reservoir management) to cut per-barrel costs. With the cash flows, fund shareholders AND allocate a meaningful portion (e.g., 15-20% of capex, rising over time) to renewables and new energy. For oil majors and large utilities, this likely means growing a renewables pipeline (wind, solar, battery storage) either organically or via acquisition – scale matters, so consider acquiring specialist developers to ramp up capabilities quickly.
Action: Set clear metrics – for instance, target X GW of renewable capacity by 2028 or aim for a certain revenue share from clean energy by 2030. By signaling these targets, you also reassure stakeholders that you’re serious about transition, helping align employees and defuse activist criticism. But ensure new investments meet hurdle rates – use your trading and market expertise to structure PPAs (power purchase agreements) and partnerships that secure acceptable returns in renewables where competition is fierce.
Innovate in Low-Carbon Technologies (and Policy Shape):
Beyond wind/solar, position your company in emerging low-carbon tech that leverages your core strengths. Strategic moves: If you’re an oil & gas player, natural extensions include carbon capture and storage (CCS) – use your subsurface expertise to store CO2 for industrial clients, turning carbon management into a business line (the IRS 45Q credit increases to $85/ton for captured CO2 under IRA, making some CCS projects viable).
Also explore hydrogen: invest in pilot projects for blue hydrogen (from gas with CCS) or green hydrogen (via electrolysis using renewables) – hydrogen can repurpose gas pipelines and keep gas relevant in a net-zero world. If you’re a utility, innovate in energy storage and grid management – perhaps launch a ‘virtual power plant’ program coordinating thousands of home batteries and EVs to stabilize the grid, which could defer expensive infrastructure upgrades.
Engage in policy dialogues – for instance, help shape hydrogen regulations or capacity market designs that reward flexible generation – to ensure new markets develop in a way that values reliability and your contributions. Many of these technologies may not pay off until late 2020s, but early movers will gain expertise and favorable positions (e.g., securing prime CO2 storage sites, or locking in long-term contracts for clean hydrogen supply to steelmakers or data centers eager to go green).
Operational Excellence and Resilience:
Traditional energy operations must not be neglected; in fact, they should be fortified. Imperative: Double down on operational excellence to drive efficiency and lower emissions of current operations. Use advanced analytics and AI in operations – for instance, predictive maintenance on refineries and power plants to minimize downtime, or AI-driven drilling algorithms that improved shale well yields by, say, 5-10%. Every dollar saved or barrel extra recovered is crucial in a world of moderate prices.
Resilience is key too: develop robust scenarios for various price environments and disruptive events. After Europe’s crisis, ensure your gas trading arm is world-class – volatility is opportunity if managed well (some companies made windfall trading LNG in 2022, those capabilities should be institutionalized). Protect assets from extreme weather – harden offshore platforms against stronger hurricanes, bury power lines or create microgrids in wildfire-prone areas to reduce outages. Supply chain: qualify multiple suppliers for critical equipment (turbines, pipes) and maintain strategic inventories (of spare parts, etc.) to avoid project delays. Essentially, make your core operations so efficient and resilient that they can fund and withstand the transition ahead.
Customer-Centric Energy Solutions:
The US Energy sector is moving from commodity supply to customer solutions. Whether you’re upstream, midstream, or a utility, find ways to get closer to the end customer and capture value. Action: If you’re a utility or power producer, consider integrated offerings – for example, offer solar + storage solutions to commercial users, or EV fleet charging services to companies transitioning their delivery trucks to electric. This might involve new business models (leasing, energy-as-a-service contracts) rather than one-off sales.
Oil companies can diversify into providing electrons – e.g., expanding EV charging networks at gasoline stations (many are doing this, turning gas stations into multi-energy hubs with fast chargers). Some European oil majors are acquiring electricity retailers to directly sell power to homes and EV owners. Industrial gas suppliers can bundle carbon management with fuel supply (sell natural gas plus take CO2 back).
By understanding and serving customers’ evolving energy needs (which increasingly include decarbonization goals), you create new revenue streams and a defensible market position. Moreover, a customer-centric approach helps in B2B relationships – e.g., an oil company forming long-term partnerships with airlines to supply not just jet fuel but also sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) solutions to meet their emission targets.
Talent and Narrative for the Transition:
The US energy sector must win the war for talent to execute all of the above – which is challenging when some young engineers perceive oil & gas as “sunset” industries.
Imperative: Craft a compelling narrative and value proposition for employees. Emphasize the role your company plays in both powering the world and protecting the planet. For example, highlight projects in renewable energy, innovation in carbon reduction, community investments – show that working at your firm means being at the forefront of solving big, tangible problems. Create career paths that allow professionals to rotate between traditional and new energy divisions, keeping talent engaged and skilled across domains. Upskill your workforce: provide training programs for petroleum engineers to learn geothermal or carbon storage skills, for electrical engineers to learn digital grid management, etc.
Culturally, encourage the mindset that safety, sustainability, and efficiency are equal pillars – many energy companies have world-class safety cultures; extend that discipline to environmental performance and innovation adoption. Recognize and reward teams for ideas that cut emissions or improve community relations, not just for hitting production targets. By doing so, you build an organization ready to lead in the new energy era and attract mission-driven talent.
For energy executives, the next few years will define whether your company remains a leader or becomes a laggard.
Call to action: Be proactive and bold. The policy winds (like the IRA) and market trends (investor ESG focus, customer demand for clean energy) are tailwinds if harnessed, headwinds if ignored. Boards should insist on clear transition plans with measurable interim targets (e.g., emissions intensity reductions, growth of new energy revenue) and hold management accountable.
At the same time, boards must ensure continued focus on core profitability and risk management – the cash from today’s operations is the fuel for tomorrow’s transformation. As a top executive, articulate a vision where your company is part of the climate solution while continuing to reliably fuel the economy. This narrative is not just for press releases – it should guide capital allocation, org structure, and R&D priorities.
The current transition in the US Energy sector is often called a once-in-a-century shift – the leaders who capitalize on it will secure decades of growth, those who drag their feet may not survive the disruption. The time to act is now, by aligning strategy to the current and future energy landscape in equal measure.
This report’s evaluation, analysis, and strategic insights are powered by Nexstrat.ai. To see Nexstrat.ai in action and learn how it can enhance your strategy development and decision-making, schedule a demo at nexstrat.ai/book-a-demo.
About NexStrat AI:
NexStrat AI is at the forefront of AI and business strategy innovation. As the ultimate strategy and transformation AI co-pilot and platform, we help leaders and strategists craft winning strategies and make effective decisions with speed and confidence.
Contact Us:
Have questions or want to learn more? Contact us at [email protected]
Follow Us:
Join our community of forward-thinking business leaders on LinkedIn.
